Author: Robert Lupton
Review By: G. Stephen Goode
I picked up this book after learning that Robert Lupton had worked alongside John Perkins, chairing the board of the Christian Community Development Association (CCDA), and had served Chicago's inner city for over three decades. John Perkins is one of my heroes, and his books have mentored me for more than 25 years. I figured Mr. Lupton would have something worthwhile to say about poverty, justice and making a difference. The title also caught my attention with a phrase anyone who has worked with the poor for long comes to recognize: the need for "rethinking ministry to the poor." This simple yet profound book did not disappoint, and it is essential reading for every church with outreach to the poor, along with every church leader, volunteer and business person.
The book begins with Jesus as our model and with what he taught about the poor, the downtrodden and the oppressed, about evangelism, the Kingdom of God, doing justice, loving mercy and walking humbly with God. If we are going to be like Jesus, our Gospel must be relevant to those we serve and those we help develop. That is where this book's journey starts: moving from betterment to community development, from starting food co-ops to buying land and welcoming mixed-income families into communities. I have read it through twice. You will be greatly encouraged as you read, even though it also honestly shares the challenges, difficulties and downsides of loving our neighbor.
The worst kind of charity is doing for others what they are capable of doing for themselves. Mr. Lupton calls this betterment—doing for others—while development enables others to do for themselves. Betterment starts with a felt need, but it cannot stop there. He offers excellent examples of both successes and failures.
I want to highlight one concept that alone is worth the price of the book: exchange. He illustrates it with the example of opening a family store and charging customers for clothes instead of giving them away free from a community clothes closet. He writes,
"This experience revealed that people, perhaps universally, would far rather engage in legitimate exchange than be the object of another's pity. There is something in one-way giving that erodes human dignity. This kind of compassion subtly communicates to the recipient, "You have nothing of value that I desire in return." One-way mercy ministry, as kind hearted as the giver may be and as well-intentioned, is an unmistakable form of put-down.
On the other hand, everyone loves to engage in the process of exchange. Everyone loves to find a bargain. There is something life affirming when someone comes to the bargaining table with a resource to barter. The playing field is leveled. The eyeing of each other's commodity takes place from both sides of the bargaining table.
Both sides have a choice; both sides weigh the worth of the other's commodity. A deal is struck, an exchange is made. And remarkably, both parties leave the encounter feeling like they have gained more value than they brought. "
We are using this book to rethink our ministry to the poor both locally and globally. It is already changing our thinking and our actions, and it will change yours too.
Purchase Compassion, Justice and the Christian Life on Amazon